Extradition from the United States to Mexico: Legal Requirements and Risks

Understanding Extradition to Mexico: What You Need to Know Before It’s Too Late

Extradition from the United States to Mexico is one of the most serious and stressful legal situations a person can face. For U.S. citizens, dual nationals, or foreigners living abroad, the idea of being sent to another country to face criminal charges raises immediate fear, uncertainty, and confusion.

As a criminal defense attorney with extensive experience in Mexico’s adversarial criminal justice system, I can tell you this clearly: extradition is not automatic, and it is not hopeless. But it is highly technical, time-sensitive, and unforgiving if handled incorrectly.

This article explains extradition to Mexico in plain English—how it works, what crimes qualify, what legal requirements must be met, and where real defenses exist.

What Is Extradition Under Mexican Law?

Extradition is a formal legal process through which one country requests another country to surrender a person who is either:

• Accused of committing a crime, or
• Already convicted and required to serve a sentence

In Mexico, extradition is considered an administrative procedure conducted in the form of a judicial process. Importantly, an extradition request is not a declaration of guilt. It does not mean the person has been convicted, nor does it replace a criminal trial.

However, once an extradition process begins, the individual may be provisionally detained to ensure availability for transfer if extradition is granted.

What Is “Active Extradition” by Mexico?

Active extradition occurs when Mexico is the requesting country. This typically happens when:

• A Mexican arrest warrant or final sentence exists
• The individual is believed to be outside Mexican territory
• Mexico formally asks another country—often the United States—to surrender that person

This is different from passive extradition, where Mexico receives a request from a foreign government.

Active extradition is frequently used in cases involving fugitives who left Mexico during an investigation or after charges were filed.

Legal Framework Governing Extradition to Mexico

Extradition to Mexico is primarily governed by:

1. International extradition treaties between Mexico and the requested country
2. Mexico’s International Extradition Law, applied when treaties allow or are silent
3. Mexican criminal procedure law, which requires a valid arrest warrant or final judgment

Even though Mexican extradition law focuses heavily on requests made to Mexico, it also authorizes and regulates extradition requests made by Mexico through treaties and international cooperation.

In practical terms, no extradition request is valid without a lawful judicial basis in Mexico.

What Crimes Qualify for Extradition to Mexico?

Not all crimes qualify. Extradition depends on both treaty provisions and Mexican law, but generally:

• Intentional crimes must be punishable in both countries with a prison sentence averaging at least one year
• Negligent or non-intentional crimes must be considered serious and punishable by incarceration
• The conduct must be criminal in both jurisdictions (dual criminality)

Examples may include homicide, fraud, organized crime offenses, serious financial crimes, kidnapping, and certain violent offenses.

Minor offenses and conduct that is not criminal in the requested country do not qualify.

Key Legal Requirements for Extradition to Mexico

For extradition to proceed, several strict conditions must be met:

1. Dual Criminality

The alleged conduct must be a crime under both Mexican law and the law of the requested country.

2. Seriousness of the Offense

Extradition is reserved for serious crimes, not misdemeanors or administrative violations.

3. Valid Mexican Judicial Order

There must be a valid arrest warrant, formal charging order, or final criminal judgment issued by a Mexican court.

4. Proper Documentation

Mexico must submit detailed documentation, including:

• Clear factual allegations
• Legal classification of the crime
• Evidence of probable responsibility or a final conviction
• Identity and location information

5. No Grounds for Denial

Extradition may be denied if:

• The crime is time-barred
• The person was already tried or acquitted
• The offense falls under treaty exceptions (such as certain political offenses)

Failure to meet any of these requirements can stop the extradition.

---

The Typical Extradition Process to Mexico

For extradition to proceed, several strict conditions must be met:

1.Dual Criminality

The alleged conduct must be a crime under both Mexican law and the law of the requested country.

2.Seriousness of the Offense

Extradition is reserved for serious crimes, not misdemeanors or administrative violations.

3. Valid Mexican Judicial Order

There must be a valid arrest warrant, formal charging order, or final criminal judgment issued by a Mexican court.

4. Proper Documentation

Mexico must submit detailed documentation, including:

• Clear factual allegations
• Legal classification of the crime
• Evidence of probable responsibility or a final conviction
• Identity and location information

5.No Grounds for Denial

Extradition may be denied if:

• The crime is time-barred
• The person was already tried or acquitted
• The offense falls under treaty exceptions (such as certain political offenses)

Failure to meet any of these requirements can stop the extradition.

The Typical Extradition Process to Mexico

While each case is unique, the process usually follows these steps:

1. A Mexican judge issues an arrest warrant or sentence
2. Mexican authorities prepare a formal extradition request
3. The request is transmitted through diplomatic or treaty channels
4. The requested country evaluates legality, evidence, and human rights concerns
5. Provisional detention may occur
6. If approved, the individual is surrendered to Mexican authorities

Each phase presents strategic opportunities for legal defense.

Why Early Legal Defense Is Critical

Extradition cases are won or lost before the final decision is made. Mistakes, omissions, or delays can permanently limit defense options.

An experienced attorney who understands both U.S. legal standards and Mexican criminal law can:

• Challenge documentation
• Raise treaty defenses
• Protect constitutional and human rights
• Prevent unnecessary or unlawful surrender

Waiting is often the most damaging decision.

Extradition to Mexico is complex, intimidating, and deeply personal. But it is not mechanical, and it is not inevitable. Legal strategy, timing, and experience matter more here than in almost any other criminal process.

If you or a loved one is facing possible extradition to Mexico, do not navigate this alone.
Contact us immediately for a confidential consultation and strategic legal guidance before irreversible decisions are made.